June 29, 2024

This post may contain affiliate links, which means I make a small commission off items you purchase at no additional cost to you. Please read my disclaimer page.

Jump to Recipe·Print Recipe· 5 from 15 reviews

I have been loving these popsicles! They’re flavorful and so refreshing. These Cherry Lime Popsicles are perfect for a summertime snack or dessert, and they are kid-approved, too!! They’re also nourishing and low calorie (only 60 calories per popsicle!), since they’re made with simple ingredients like cherries, yogurt, and maple syrup as the sweetener.

Nutritional benefits of this recipe

Cherries are packed full of beneficial antioxidants and nutrients. They’re also delicious!
Yogurt adds healthy protein and fat to these popsicles, making them a more balanced snack that’s satiating and blood sugar balancing.
Maple syrup is a natural sweetener (from the sap of maple trees) so it’s healthy and also rich in antioxidants and minerals such as manganese, riboflavin, and copper.
These popsicles only have 60 calories each, so they’re a great low-calorie snack or dessert option that still tastes amazing and satisfies a sweet tooth.

Ingredients in Cherry Lime Popsicles

Frozen cherries – I used dark sweet cherries.

Yogurt – To add healthy fats and protein. The fat in the yogurt helps to make the popsicles less “icy”, so I recommend using whole milk yogurt rather than greek or low-fat yogurt which would make an icy popsicle. If you are dairy-free, then feel free to sub canned coconut milk 1:1 with the yogurt. I personally prefer the “classic” (full-fat) canned coconut milk, but the light coconut milk will work too (make sure it’s from a can – it’s different than that from a carton).

Lime juice – I put just 1/2 of a lime in this recipe, so it’s only a slight tanginess and hint of flavor. If you want the popsicles more tangy, then use juice from the whole lime or even add some lime zest.

Pure almond extract – This part is important in my opinion! Almond extract really brings out the cherry flavor and adds another layer of sweetness to the recipe (even though it’s sugar free), so I prefer it over vanilla extract for this recipe. However, if vanilla is all you have on hand, then no problem. You can use vanilla extract instead, but I would increase it to 1 tsp (almond extract is way stronger).

Maple syrup – as the sweetener. You can also sub honey, but honey does have a strong flavor that would show through, just FYI! It would still be delicious though.

How to make Cherry Lime Popsicles

Add 15 oz of the cherries to the blender along with the yogurt, lime juice, pure almond extract, and maple syrup. Blend well.
Evening disperse the mixture between 10 of the popsicle molds (if using the same as me). You’ll want to leave a couple inches at the top to leave space for the chopped cherries.
Chop up the remaining cherries then put them into the popsicle molds with the popsicle mixture. This adds delicious cherry chunks to the popsicles. You can use a butter knife or popsicle stick to push the chopped cherries down into the molds.
Put the top on the molds then place food-grade popsicle sticks into the holes.
Place in the freezer for 4-6 hours, or until completely frozen.
Transfer the popsicles into wrappers and store in the freezer. Eat within couple months for best flavor.

Modifications

For dairy-free: Either sub GT’s Cocoyo for the regular yogurt, or you can sub canned coconut milk for the yogurt. I recommend canned coconut milk rather than that from a carton because it has more fat in it, which helps the popsicles be less icy. Full-fat is preferred, but light will work as well.
Sub 1 tsp vanilla extract in place of the almond extract if that’s all you have on hand. I do recommend trying it with almond extract eventually, though, because it’s the absolute BEST flavor with these cherries.
For tangy popsicles: Add juice from the whole lime.
For super tangy popsicles: Add juice from the whole lime and add the zest from the lime as well.
Other sweeteners you can use: You can sub honey 1:1 in place of the maple syrup, just be aware that the honey flavor will probably show through (still absolutely delicious!). You can also sweeten the popsicles with dates. I would do 6-8 large dates and blend it super well during the first step to make sure it’s completely blended and there aren’t chunks of dates (you’ll want the sweetness fully incorporated).

Other recipes you’ll love

Easy Mango Popsicles

Berry Coconut Popsicles

Whole Banana Popsicles

I hope you love these Cherry Lime Popsicles! Please be sure to leave a comment and rating if you try this recipe. It helps me out so much, and I love hearing from you!